I do not know how many tents I
have owned and used over the years. Quite a few of them. Even now there are
four tents in our pile of gear that we employ in our assorted outdoor doings. A
couple of modern tents, a canvas wall tent, and a small canvas A-frame.
Tents have some good things going
for them, especially the modern ones with the sewn in floors and screened
windows. Warm weather insects and crawling creatures have a difficult time getting inside to
bother you. They do also afford you some indoor privacy when camping in
developed sites where other people are around.
They also have some not so good
things about them that make them impractical to carry on our backs when our two
feet and legs become our mode of transportation … their size and weight being two primary issues … and that pack on
our back is our home away from home.
The Big Four
Fire, Water, Shelter, Food
When it comes to shelter it just
does not get any simpler than a tarp. One of the beautiful things about a tarp
is that their simplicity lends itself to a lot of set-up versatility.
A sewn tent, regardless of its
style, is designed to be set up one
way. If any of the parts are broken or lost there is a serious problem when it
comes time to set up camp. A very close at hand example of this came last weekend on
our overnight outing.
We took along our large dome tent
for Shirli and our little pooch. I felt no need to check it out before we
loaded it. We had used it in the spring and everything was intact and in good
usable condition when it was taken down and packed.
So we get to our destination and
begin setting up. I unrolled the tent and got it into position. All was well. I
pulled out the flex-corded poles and discovered that the shock cords on both
sets had decided between spring and fall to literally fall apart.
That roll of gorilla tape in my
kit had to be employed to hold the pole sections together and save the day. It
took a little time to tape all those sections together. It took longer to tape
the two sets of poles together than it did to construct my tarp shelter and lay
out my bedroll. Had time been an urgent matter it would not have been a good
situation.
About the worst thing that can go
wrong with a tarp is to have a grommet tear out. But that is a simple problem
to remedy.
Unpacking, setting up, taking
down, and repacking a tent, even a small one, can be something of a chore that
takes a generous amount of time. Even on a good day. A wet tent is just short
of a nightmare.
There are times when available
time is a crucial matter. Maybe daylight is growing short and you need to get a
camp set. Maybe a fast moving weather front is approaching and you need to get
yourself and your gear under shelter before the bottom falls out.
With a tarp you can be set up, hunkered
down under shelter, and ready for a storm in five minutes. Or, in better
weather, that few minutes of constructing shelter allows more time to gather
firewood for the night, prepare your evening meal, boil water for drinking, and
enjoy that mystical transitional time when the day critters go silent and the
night critters begin their chorus.
Poly vs. Canvas
There is an awful lot of
commotion and debate going on in the woodcraft-bushcraft-survival circle about
this and what I offer here is simply my two copper cents worth on the issue.
I think the debate is a bunch of
guff unless what you are attempting
to achieve is a good authentic looking replica of a kit carried by a
frontiersman prior to or during the Longhunter Era. If that is the case then
there is no room in a kit for paracord, ferro rods, Bic Lighters, Pardner 12
Gauge shotguns fitted for using Black Powder, titanium or stainless bush pots,
modern material clothing, and quite a lot of other modern imaginations.
What I see too often in this
debate is what I call bushcraft bravado
… that my kit is better than your
kit because I have this, that or the other ego stroking thing.
Personally, I do not have any
interest in adding the extra pounds of an oilcloth tarp to my kit.
Besides, for the cost of a good
oilcloth, the average person can put together a good usable kit that will get
them started and serve them well for quite a long time. A rain fly from a
defunct tent makes a good usable shelter. That is what I am using in the
picture at the top of the page. I picked up this one and a blue one at the
Coleman Store for $3.00 each.
A good quality poly-tarp serves
me well and I do have a preference for woodland camouflage. It blends well in a
woodland environment. We paid a little more for the ones we ordered and have in
our personal kits. You will not find them at Walmart or any of the discount
stores.
Debris Huts
I place debris huts in the same
category as friction fire. Knowing how to build one is something good to know
and something that does not require a degree in drafting or building
construction.
If we have a means to construct
shelter in our kit then there is no need to invest the energy and time to build
a debris hut unless we discover ourselves in an unexpected long-term situation
with winter coming on and need the extra insulation against the cold.
Another thing to consider is
that, unless you own the property or have the owners permission where you will
be cutting living saplings to use in constructing a debris hut, you had better
not do it. National Forests, State
Forests , and State Parks
have usage stipulations that need to be adhered to. Step outside those
stipulations and you might very well find yourself paying a hefty fine and
discover yourself banned from future access.